Skip to content
← Resources / Articles
Diligence4 min read

Twelve diligence findings that change the price

Not the exotic ones. The twelve that actually come up, what each one costs a seller, and which of them can still be fixed before a buyer looks.

All M&A Research

Financial diligence

Updated
Rows of old metal filing cabinets with handwritten labels.
Rows of old metal filing cabinets with handwritten labels.

Key takeaways

  • Nothing found in diligence stays neutral. Every finding becomes a price adjustment, an indemnity, a condition, or an exclusion from warranty insurance.
  • The findings that cost most are structural, title, concentration, owner dependence, and they cannot be fixed inside a process.
  • The findings that cost least are the ones the seller raised first, with evidence attached.
  • Most of this list is discoverable by the seller for a fraction of what it costs when a buyer finds it during exclusivity.

The short answer. Twelve findings account for most of the value lost in diligence on mid-market deals. They are listed below in rough order of what they cost, with what each one does to the deal and whether it can still be fixed.

The governing point first: there is no category of finding that gets noted and set aside. Each one becomes a reduction in price, a specific indemnity, a condition to completion, or an exclusion from warranty insurance. That is the case for finding them yourself.

1. Defective title to the shares

What it is. The share register does not reconcile to the cap table. An old transfer was never stamped, an option was granted without authority, a deceased shareholder’s holding was never properly transmitted.

What it costs. This one does not get priced: it gets fixed, or the deal stops. A buyer cannot acquire what the seller cannot prove it owns.

Fixable? Yes, and it should be done before a process starts. It is also the cheapest item on this list to resolve.

2. Customer concentration

What it is. One customer at thirty per cent or more of revenue, particularly on rolling orders rather than a contract.

What it costs. It gets priced in five places at once: the multiple, an earn-out, a larger escrow, a condition about the contract, and a specific warranty. Sellers argue the multiple and concede the rest. The full arithmetic is here.

Fixable? Only over two to three years.

3. Owner dependence

What it is. Every significant decision and relationship runs through one person who is leaving.

What it costs. Consideration moves from completion to deferred: an earn-out, a lock-in, a retention escrow, longer restrictive covenants.

Fixable? Eighteen months to two years of deliberate delegation, with evidence. What that looks like.

4. Accounts that do not reconcile

What it is. Statutory accounts, management accounts and the adjusted figures do not tie to each other.1

What it costs. More than the discrepancy. It slows every other workstream while the diligence team rebuilds the numbers, and it recasts every other claim in the information memorandum as something to re-check.

Fixable? Yes, in six to twelve months, and it is the highest-return preparation available.

5. Revenue recognised early

What it is. Invoiced ahead of delivery, or a project recognised on signature rather than on progress.

What it costs. An EBITDA adjustment, multiplied by the valuation multiple. At 7×, £200,000 of restated revenue timing is £1.4m.

Fixable? The policy can be corrected going forward. The restatement of prior years cannot.

6. Under-accrued costs

What it is. Holiday pay, bonuses, deferred maintenance, warranty provisions: real obligations not fully carried in the accounts.

What it costs. Either an EBITDA adjustment or a debt-like deduction from the price, and occasionally both if the two schedules are not compared. Watch for the double count.

Fixable? Yes. Accrue properly before the process.

7. Contracts without change-of-control protection

What it is. Material contracts that terminate, or require consent, on a change of control, and nobody checked before going to market.

What it costs. A condition to completion that puts the counterparty in your negotiation, and a timetable you do not control. On an asset sale the issue is universal rather than selective.

Fixable? Partly: a renewal or a waiver obtained before the process is worth a great deal.

8. Employment status of contractors

What it is. People treated as self-employed who, on the facts, are employees.

What it costs. A tax indemnity, usually uncapped and outside the general warranty cap, because neither side can size it precisely.

Fixable? Yes, but the historic exposure remains. Take advice early.

9. Intellectual property that is not owned

What it is. Code written by a contractor without an assignment. A brand never registered. A domain in a former employee’s personal account.

What it costs. In a technology or brand-led business, this can be the whole value. In others it is a condition and a chase.

Fixable? Usually yes, cheaply, if started early. Expensively if the contractor has to be found during exclusivity.

10. A cyber incident disclosed late

What it is. A past breach, particularly one that was reportable.

What it costs. Not usually the incident. The lateness: a buyer that learns about it in week eight starts testing everything else, and diligence scoped at six weeks becomes ten.

Fixable? The disclosure timing is entirely within your control, which is the point.

11. Working capital that was never analysed

What it is. No monthly working capital history, so the peg is set from the buyer’s chosen twelve months.

What it costs. Pound for pound off the price, invisibly. The worked example.

Fixable? Yes: build twenty-four months of analysis before going to market.

12. A pension deficit nobody scoped

What it is. A defined benefit scheme whose funding position has not been assessed for a transaction.

What it costs. Potentially the shape of the entire deal, including whether a share sale is possible at all.

Fixable? Not quickly. Get it assessed before anything else.

The pattern

Look at the “fixable?” lines together and the structure is obvious. The items that can be fixed cheaply (title, reconciliation, accruals, IP assignments, working capital analysis, disclosure sequencing) are fixable only before a buyer is looking. The items that cannot be fixed quickly are the ones that cost the most.

Which means the value of preparation is not that it makes the business look better. It is that it moves six of these twelve findings out of the exclusivity period, when a seller has no leverage, into the months beforehand, when they have all of it.

The due diligence checklist sets out what a buyer will ask for, workstream by workstream, and what each request is testing.

Sources

  1. CBIZ, “Sell-Side Quality of Earnings: A Critical Part of Due Diligence”. ↩