Deal structure
Asset sale or share sale is not a technical question
Buyers want assets and sellers want shares, for the same reason: one of them leaves the history behind. Where that argument land…
9 November 2026 · 4 min
Earn-outs rarely fail because a buyer acted in bad faith. They fail because a reasonable new owner made reasonable decisions, and the metric you agreed to was never designed to survive them.
All M&A Research
Sell-side structuring
Updated
Key takeaways
Ask a room of founders who have sold their businesses what they would negotiate differently, and the answers cluster. A few mention price. Almost none mention legal fees. The overwhelming majority mention the earn-out, not that they accepted one, but that they negotiated the wrong parts of it.
The pattern is consistent enough to be worth writing down, because it is entirely avoidable and it is one of the largest single transfers of value in mid-market M&A.
An earn-out converts part of your purchase price into a contingent claim, measured by an accounting metric, calculated by the person who now controls the business, over a period during which you have limited or no authority to influence the outcome.
Stated that way, most sellers would negotiate differently. Stated as “twenty per cent of the consideration, payable on hitting the plan you wrote,” it sounds like a formality. The plan is yours. The business is performing. Why would you not hit it?
Because the business you wrote the plan for stops existing at completion.
Before the failure modes, the shape of the thing. In SRS Acquiom’s 2026 study of more than 2,300 private-target deals closed between 2020 and 2025, earn-outs appeared in 24% of 2025 transactions: above the historic average of roughly 20%, below the 33% peak of 2023.1
Two figures from that study matter more than the prevalence:
So the typical earn-out is not a token, and the typical measurement period is short enough that a single disrupted quarter is a material share of it. Both facts argue for spending the negotiation on the metric rather than the number.
The metric moves because the cost base changes. You agreed to EBITDA. The buyer allocates group overhead to your business: a management charge, a share of the group insurance, a contribution to the shared ERP programme. None of this is improper; it is how groups account. Your EBITDA falls by an amount that has nothing to do with the trading you were measured on.
The metric moves because of an investment you would have made anyway. The buyer hires eight salespeople to accelerate growth. Excellent decision. The cost lands in year one; the revenue lands in year three; your earn-out period ends in year two.
Integration consumes the thing being measured. A systems migration, a rebrand, a change of distributor, a consolidation of your warehouse into theirs. Each is defensible, each disrupts trading for a quarter, and your two-year window has eight quarters in it.
Revenue is recognised differently. Your accounting policy for a multi-year contract meets the buyer’s group policy. Nobody has done anything wrong and your top line changes shape.
The strategy changes. The buyer decides your lowest-margin product line is not worth having, or that your biggest customer conflicts with a group relationship. Revenue-based earn-out, deliberately reduced revenue, no bad faith required.
Change of control mid-period. The buyer is itself acquired, or the sponsor sells. Your counterparty is now a party that has never met you and inherited an obligation it did not negotiate.
In none of these cases does anyone need to behave badly for the seller to be paid nothing. That is the point. Bad faith is the rare case; ordinary business is the common one.
The headline earn-out amount is the least important term. In descending order of what actually determines whether you get paid:
Prefer, in order: a discrete verifiable event (a contract signed, an approval granted, a facility commissioned), then revenue or gross profit, then EBITDA. The further down the income statement you go, the more of the buyer’s decisions sit between you and your money. Gross profit is a reasonable compromise in many businesses: harder to manipulate than EBITDA, more meaningful than revenue.
If it must be EBITDA, define it in a schedule that fixes the accounting policies as at completion, excludes group allocations and management charges, excludes acquisition and integration costs, excludes buyer-directed investment above an agreed threshold, and specifies the treatment of anything unusual. A one-page definition is not a definition.
You need contractual commitments about how the business will be run during the period: that it will be operated as a separate reporting unit, that agreed accounting policies will not change, that key customers and product lines will not be discontinued without consent, that no group costs will be pushed in, and that reasonable resources will continue to be provided. Buyers resist these because they constrain integration, which is exactly why an earn-out and an aggressive integration plan are fundamentally incompatible, and why one of the two should give way.
If you are staying, what decisions do you actually control? A seller with P&L authority and hiring rights has a fighting chance. A seller reporting to a divisional VP with a group budget process does not. If you are leaving, an earn-out is a bet on someone else’s execution and should be priced as one.
Monthly management accounts as of right, in a specified format, with a window to query. An expert-determination clause with a named class of expert, a short timetable and cost allocation. Without it, your remedy is litigation against a better-capitalised counterparty over a definition you agreed to.
Full acceleration on: change of control of the buyer, disposal of your business, termination of your employment other than for cause, and material breach of the protective covenants. This single clause has saved more earn-outs than every other provision combined.
Shorter is better. Two years of measurement is already long enough for a business to be substantially altered. Three years plus an integration is an option, not a receivable.
Compare offers on a risk-adjusted basis before you choose one, not after you sign. Take the deferred component, apply a discount that reflects the actual probability of payment: for a genuine EBITDA earn-out with weak covenants and no acceleration, something between forty and sixty per cent is not cynical, and add it to the cash. Then rank the offers.
Sellers who do this frequently discover that the offer they were about to reject as “lower” is worth more, closes faster, and does not require them to spend two years watching someone else operate their company while their money sits on the outcome.
There are real cases. Where a genuine, near-term, verifiable event will resolve a specific uncertainty, a regulatory approval, a pending contract renewal, a product launch already in flight, a milestone payment lets both sides transact without arguing about a probability. Where the seller is staying with real authority and the earn-out is genuinely aligned incentive rather than deferred price, it can work well.
The test is whether the contingency is something you control and something that resolves cleanly. If it is neither, you have not bridged a valuation gap. You have financed the buyer.
General commentary, not legal or financial advice; earn-out drafting requires specialist counsel.
SRS Acquiom’s 2026 private-target M&A deal terms study, covering more than 2,300 transactions closed between 2020 and 2025, as summarised in Fasken, “Private M&A Deal Trends to Watch: Key Takeaways from SRS Acquiom’s 2026 Study” (7 May 2026). The sample is predominantly US buyers, so treat the levels as a reference point rather than a UK market rate. ↩
Related
Deal structure
Buyers want assets and sellers want shares, for the same reason: one of them leaves the history behind. Where that argument land…
9 November 2026 · 4 min
Tools
No single room wins every deal, so this is organised by the process you are running rather than as a ranking. With what each pro…
9 November 2026 · 11 min
Exit planning
A trade sale, a sponsor, a management buyout, a serial acquirer or passing it on. Each pays differently, takes a different amoun…
9 November 2026 · 5 min