Deal structure
Asset sale or share sale is not a technical question
Buyers want assets and sellers want shares, for the same reason: one of them leaves the history behind. Where that argument land…
9 November 2026 · 4 min
Regulatory review used to be a post-signing formality. In cross-border deals it has become the item that sets the timetable, shapes the price, and occasionally decides whether a buyer can bid at all.
All M&A Research
Cross-border and regulatory
Updated
Key takeaways
A decade ago, a cross-border acquisition of a mid-market industrial business would have treated national security review as a checklist item. A filing, a waiting period, a clearance letter. Today the same deal may face three separate screening regimes, none of which existed in its current form when the buyer last transacted, and the aggregate timetable can exceed the patience of the seller’s board.
The shift matters because it changes when regulatory work happens. Screening is no longer something you manage after signing. It is a bidding-stage question: can this buyer credibly clear, how long will it take, and what is the seller being asked to accept in the meantime?
The mechanics differ, and the sequencing is where deals get into trouble.
National security review of the inbound investment. Most major jurisdictions now screen acquisitions of domestic businesses by foreign buyers, and the definition of a sensitive sector has widened well beyond defence. Data about citizens, critical infrastructure, dual-use technology, advanced materials, agricultural land, ports and logistics, and in several jurisdictions anything adjacent to semiconductors or AI capability. A business that considers itself an unremarkable component supplier may sit inside three of those categories.
The UK regime is a useful illustration because it is written down. The National Security and Investment Act 2021 makes an acquisition of control notifiable, and completion unlawful without approval, where the target carries on activities in any of seventeen specified areas: advanced materials, advanced robotics, artificial intelligence, civil nuclear, communications, computing hardware, critical suppliers to government, cryptographic authentication, data infrastructure, defence, energy, military and dual-use, quantum technologies, satellite and space technologies, suppliers to the emergency services, synthetic biology, and transport.1 A statutory review has proposed adding water, which would take it to nineteen.
The breadth is not theoretical. The government’s own annual report for 2025 to 2026 records sixty call-in notices, spanning sixteen of the seventeen mandatory areas, with defence the most common.2 There is no financial threshold at all: a small acquisition in a listed area is notifiable where a far larger one outside them is not.
Subsidy and state-support screening. The newer layer. Where a bidder has received financial contributions from a non-domestic government, which includes far more than direct grants: preferential loans, tax treatment, capital injections into affiliates. Some regimes now require notification and can impose conditions or prohibit the transaction. This catches state-backed and sovereign-linked buyers, but it also catches ordinary corporates with global operations who have never thought of themselves as subsidised.
Merger control. The oldest of the three and the one buyers plan for. Still capable of surprises where a deal creates a plausible theory of harm in a narrow market, or where filings are required in a long tail of jurisdictions because of local turnover thresholds.
The clocks do not run neatly in parallel. Some regimes will not start their substantive review until another has concluded. Others require information you can only produce after the first has asked for it. A sequencing error can add a quarter to a timetable without anyone doing anything wrong.
Sellers have adapted faster than buyers, and the adaptation is not in the seller’s favour to concede.
Regulatory risk is now priced into bid selection. A seller comparing two offers within a few per cent of each other will take the one that clears in eight weeks over the one that might clear in eight months. This is the single most important consequence of the shift: a domestic buyer with a lower headline number frequently wins. Cross-border buyers who do not understand that they are competing on certainty as well as price lose processes they thought they had won.
Conditionality has become a negotiated commodity. Expect sellers to push for hell-or-high-water covenants (the buyer must do whatever is required to clear, including divestments), reverse break fees payable if clearance fails, ticking fees that increase the price the longer the wait runs, and outside dates that are short enough to hurt. Each of these is a real economic term and each should be priced.
Diligence now runs on the buyer. Sellers increasingly conduct their own diligence on the acquirer’s ownership structure, government relationships and prior filings, because the seller carries the cost of a failed clearance in lost time, lost momentum and a business that has been in a data room for six months.
The question a seller’s board now asks first is not “what is the price?” It is “will this actually close, and when?” Cross-border buyers who cannot answer that in one sentence are already behind.
Among buyers who clear cleanly, a few patterns repeat.
Screen yourself before you bid. Map your own ownership chain, government-linked shareholders, subsidies received across all affiliates, and prior filings: before the first meeting. Buyers who discover a state-linked minority investor three weeks into a filing have already lost the seller’s confidence.
Get pre-filing engagement where it exists. Several regimes allow informal pre-notification contact. It is slow, it feels optional, and it is frequently the difference between a clean clearance and a second-phase review.
File early on the regime with the longest clock, not the easiest one. The temptation is to bank a quick clearance first. The timetable is set by the slowest process, so start it first, even if it means filing with incomplete information and supplementing.
Design the mitigation you would accept. Most conditional clearances involve commitments: local governance arrangements, security agreements, data localisation, ring-fenced facilities, sometimes a divestment. Buyers who arrive with a proposed package negotiate from a much better position than buyers who wait to be told.
Write the timetable into the deal terms honestly. An outside date you know is optimistic is not a negotiating win. It is a re-trade waiting to happen, at the moment when you have the least leverage.
Nothing in the current direction of travel suggests these regimes will loosen. The sectors considered sensitive continue to expand, and the number of jurisdictions running some form of screening keeps rising. The practical implication for anyone building a cross-border thesis is that regulatory capability is now part of the investment case, not an execution detail, and firms that have built it internally are winning assets that would previously have gone to whoever bid highest.
For sellers, the corollary is worth stating plainly: running a genuinely global process now costs you time, and the time has a price. That price should be paid knowingly, in exchange for competitive tension, rather than discovered in month seven.
General commentary, not legal advice; specific filings require specialist counsel in each jurisdiction.
Department for Business and Trade, “National Security and Investment Act: details of the 17 types of notifiable acquisitions”, and the NSI Act collection. The areas are defined by the Notifiable Acquisition (Specification of Qualifying Entities) Regulations 2021; check the collection page for the current list before relying on it. ↩
National Security and Investment Act 2021 Annual Report 2025-26. ↩
Related
Deal structure
Buyers want assets and sellers want shares, for the same reason: one of them leaves the history behind. Where that argument land…
9 November 2026 · 4 min
Tools
No single room wins every deal, so this is organised by the process you are running rather than as a ranking. With what each pro…
9 November 2026 · 11 min
Exit planning
A trade sale, a sponsor, a management buyout, a serial acquirer or passing it on. Each pays differently, takes a different amoun…
9 November 2026 · 5 min