Skip to content
← Resources / Articles
Deal mechanics3 min read

Locked box or completion accounts: the choice that decides who owns the gap

One mechanism fixes the price at a historic balance sheet and gives the buyer the risk of everything after it. The other leaves the price open for three months after completion. Neither is neutral.

All M&A Research

Financial diligence

Updated
Stacked yellow and white plastic crates in a storage area.
Stacked yellow and white plastic crates in a storage area.

Key takeaways

  • A locked box fixes the equity price at a historic balance sheet date, so economic risk and reward pass to the buyer from that date rather than from completion.
  • Completion accounts leave the final price to be calculated after the deal closes, which means the seller is negotiating while the buyer controls the books.
  • A locked box needs a reliable set of accounts at the box date and a leakage covenant. Without audited or well-diligenced numbers, buyers will not accept one.
  • Sellers should prefer a locked box in most mid-market deals, for certainty rather than for the number.

Two businesses sell for the same headline enterprise value on the same day. One seller knows exactly what will arrive in their account. The other finds out in March. The difference is a paragraph in the purchase agreement that most first-time sellers skim.

What each one does

Completion accounts are the traditional approach.1 The parties agree an enterprise value and a set of target balances, usually a working capital peg, plus definitions of cash and debt. After completion, a balance sheet is prepared as at the completion date, compared with those targets, and the price adjusts. The process typically takes 60 to 90 days, sometimes longer if there is a dispute.1

A locked box fixes the equity price by reference to a balance sheet at a date before signing. There is no post-completion adjustment. Instead, the seller covenants that nothing has leaked out of the box since that date, no dividends, no related-party payments, no bonuses outside the ordinary course, and the buyer takes the economic risk and reward of the business from the box date onward.

Who carries what

This is the whole thing, and it is simpler than the drafting suggests.

Under completion accounts, the seller keeps the economics of the business until the day it completes, and the price moves to reflect whatever actually happened. Under a locked box, the buyer owns the economics from the box date, which means it keeps the upside if trading is strong in the intervening period and bears the shortfall if it is not. Sellers are sometimes paid for that transfer through an interest charge or a cash-equivalent on the price, running from the box date to completion.

The trade is not about who gets the better number. It is about who absorbs the uncertainty of the intervening weeks, and who has to negotiate afterwards.

The asymmetry sellers underestimate

Here is the practical problem with completion accounts that no amount of careful drafting removes.

The accounts are prepared after the buyer owns the business. The buyer’s team has the ledgers, the systems, and the judgement calls. The inventory provision, the bad debt allowance, the accrual for a disputed invoice. The seller has whatever information rights the agreement gives them, a shortening window to object, and no operational access.

Every judgement in that exercise moves the price, and the party making the first draft of each judgement is the one that benefits from it. A seller can negotiate a good adjustment mechanism, an accounting policies hierarchy, a specified expert, defined access, and still be arguing from the outside.

A locked box removes that entirely. The price is fixed; the only post-completion question is whether leakage occurred, and leakage is a short, factual list rather than a set of estimates.

When a locked box is not available

Buyers do not accept one unconditionally. They need:

  • Reliable accounts at the box date. Audited is ideal; a well-diligenced management balance sheet can work. A business with weak monthly reporting will not get a locked box.
  • A short gap between the box date and completion. The longer the period, the more risk the buyer is taking blind.
  • A tight leakage definition, with permitted leakage agreed in advance, agreed salaries, an existing lease, a specified dividend, and an indemnity for anything else, usually uncapped on a pound-for-pound basis.
  • Normal trading. A business in the middle of a seasonal swing, a large contract win, or a working capital unwind is hard to price at a historic date.

Carve-outs are the usual casualty. A business being separated from a group frequently has no standalone balance sheet at any historic date, which is why those deals default to completion accounts.

What to do

For most profitable mid-market businesses with decent accounts, a locked box is the better answer for a seller, and the reason is certainty rather than quantum. A fixed price known at signing is worth more than a possibly-higher price determined three months later by the other side’s accountants.

If completion accounts are unavoidable, the things to fight for are the ones that constrain judgement: a specific accounting policies hierarchy that puts the agreed schedule above past practice and past practice above the general framework, a defined dispute route to an independent expert with a timetable, access rights that let your accountant review the working papers, and a cap or collar on how far the adjustment can move the price.

And negotiate all of it before exclusivity. The adjustment mechanism is cheap to agree while another bidder is interested and expensive afterwards.

Sources

  1. Lander & Rogers, “M&A purchase price adjustment mechanisms: completion accounts vs locked box” (September 2023). ↩ ↩2