Skip to content
← Resources / Articles
Deal mechanics4 min read

The clause your lawyer calls boilerplate is the price negotiation

After completion the buyer prepares the accounts that decide whether money comes back to it, using its own finance team and its own judgement. The only thing standing between you and that is a clause most sellers never read.

All M&A Research

Deal structure and process

Updated
A person sitting at a table covered with spread-out papers.
A person sitting at a table covered with spread-out papers.

Key takeaways

  • The buyer prepares the completion accounts, using the business it now owns and the finance team it now employs. The seller's protection is the accounting policies clause, not anyone's goodwill.
  • The hierarchy in that clause decides who wins. Specific agreed policies first, then the target's own historic policies, then the accounting framework. Reverse that order and the buyer has a free hand.
  • A buyer applying conservative policies to the same balance sheet finds more provisions and more accruals, each of which reduces working capital and therefore the price.
  • Many agreements deem the accounts agreed if the seller fails to object within a stated window. That is the entire adjustment, lost on a diary date.

There is a moment in most private company sales that almost nobody prepares for. The deal has completed, the money has moved, the parties have shaken hands, and then the buyer’s finance team sits down to prepare a set of accounts that will determine whether some of that money comes back.

That is the completion accounts process, and it is the second half of the price negotiation. It runs after the seller has lost every piece of leverage they ever had, and it is governed almost entirely by a clause that gets drafted late, reviewed quickly, and described as administrative.

Who holds the pen

Start from the structural facts, because they are not symmetrical.

After completion the buyer owns the business. It controls the accounting systems, it employs the finance team, and it instructs whoever prepares the accounts. It is also the party that benefits if working capital comes in below the agreed peg, because the difference comes off the price.

The seller, meanwhile, has no access to the records except what the agreement gives them, no staff inside the business, and a deadline to object.

None of this requires a buyer to behave improperly. It only requires a buyer to apply judgement in its own favour on a series of genuinely judgemental questions. That is what finance teams are paid to do.

The same balance sheet, two answers

Working capital is not a fact. It is the output of a series of accounting judgements: how much to provide against doubtful debts, how much inventory to write down as obsolete, what to accrue for work done but not invoiced, when revenue on a part-completed contract is recognised.

Each of those is defensible across a range. A buyer taking the conservative end of every range is not doing anything a regulator would object to.1

Take a business with an agreed peg of £1,000,000. On the target’s own historic policies, working capital at completion comes in at £1,010,000 and the seller is owed £10,000. On the buyer’s policies, with a larger bad-debt provision and an inventory write-down, the same balance sheet produces £890,000 and the seller owes £110,000. Nothing about the business has changed. One hundred and twenty thousand pounds has moved on the drafting of a single clause.

The hierarchy is the whole game

A properly drafted accounting policies clause sets out an order of precedence, and that order decides who wins the judgement calls:

  1. Specific policies set out in a schedule, written for the judgement areas you already know about: the ones that came up in diligence.
  2. Then the target’s own historic policies, applied consistently with how the peg itself was calculated.
  3. Then the applicable accounting framework.

Where that hierarchy runs the other way, framework first, historic practice last, the buyer has a free hand, because almost any provision can be justified as compliant with the framework. The framework is a floor, not a method.

The second item in the list carries more weight than it looks. If the peg was calculated on the target’s historic policies and the completion accounts are prepared on someone else’s, the comparison is between two different things, and the seller pays for the difference. The agreement should say explicitly that the two are prepared on a consistent basis.

The deadline nobody diarises

Most completion accounts mechanisms run to a timetable: the buyer prepares the accounts within sixty to ninety days, the seller has a stated window to object, then a period to resolve disputes, then a named expert decides.

Many agreements provide that if the seller does not object within the window, the accounts are deemed agreed.

That is the whole adjustment, surrendered because a date passed. It happens, and it happens most often to sellers who have left the business, moved on, and are no longer reading post-completion correspondence with full attention.

Three things to secure in the drafting, in order of how often they are missed:

  • A right to the working papers, not just the finished accounts. You cannot dispute a number whose derivation you cannot see.
  • A named independent expert, not “a firm to be agreed”. Agreeing a firm at the moment the parties have stopped agreeing is a negotiation you will lose.
  • A realistic objection window, with the clock starting from delivery of the working papers rather than the accounts.

What to do about it

The practical advice is dull and it works: negotiate the accounting policies schedule at the same time as the price, not at the end of the process.

By the time the schedule is being drafted, the price has been agreed, everyone is tired, and the clause looks like plumbing. It is the only thing standing between the figure in the letter of intent and the figure that survives. On most mid-market deals it is worth more than the warranties, and it receives a fraction of the attention.

The alternative, if you would rather not have the argument at all, is a locked box: fix the price from a historical balance sheet and have no true-up. That moves the analytical weight onto diligence of a single set of accounts, which is its own trade, but it does remove the post-completion negotiation entirely, and for some sellers that is worth more than the last few points of price.

Sources

  1. Lander & Rogers, “M&A purchase price adjustment mechanisms: completion accounts vs locked box” (September 2023). ↩