Skip to content
← Resources / Articles
Deal process4 min read

Who you actually need in the room, and what each one is paid for

A mid-market sale runs on four or five advisers whose roles overlap at the edges. Hiring the wrong combination is the most common way a seller spends six figures and still negotiates alone.

All M&A Research

Deal structure and process

Updated
An empty boardroom with an oval wooden table and leather chairs.
An empty boardroom with an oval wooden table and leather chairs.

Key takeaways

  • The corporate finance adviser's value is competitive tension and process control, not introductions. Judge candidates on how they would run the process, not on their contact list.
  • Transaction legal work is a specialism. The firm that handles commercial contracts well is not automatically the firm to draft a purchase agreement.
  • Tax advice belongs before the process, not inside it. Most structuring options close once a buyer is engaged.
  • Fee structures create incentives. A low success fee with a high retainer, or a flat percentage with no ratchet, each change how hard the last pound is fought for.

A first-time seller usually has one long-standing adviser, the accountant who has done the year-end for a decade, and assumes that relationship covers the transaction. It does not, and the gap is not competence. It is that selling a company requires four or five distinct functions, and almost nobody performs more than two of them well.

The corporate finance adviser

The one most sellers are unsure about, because the fee is the largest and the deliverable is the least tangible.

What they are actually for: running a process that produces competitive tension and holding it together while diligence tries to pull it apart. Building the information memorandum and the financial model, assembling and approaching a buyer list, managing the timetable so that bids arrive together rather than sequentially, and absorbing the negotiation so the principal is not personally arguing with the person they may work for.

That last function is undervalued and worth the fee on its own in a founder sale.

What they are not for: a list of contacts. Every adviser will say they know the buyers. The useful questions are different: how would you structure the process, how many parties would you approach and in what waves, who on your team does the work day to day, what does your fee do if the price moves, and what were the last three deals you ran in this sector and what happened to them.

When they are not needed: a bilateral sale to a known counterparty at an agreed price, where the work is legal rather than commercial. That is rarer than sellers hope, because a known counterparty at an agreed price is usually a buyer who knows there is no competition.

Transaction counsel

Distinct from commercial legal work, and the distinction matters.

A purchase agreement is a specialist document. The warranty schedule, the disclosure regime, the adjustment mechanism, the indemnity structure, the tax covenant. These are drafted by people who draft them weekly. A capable general commercial firm handling its first purchase agreement of the year will produce something that works and will miss the market position on half a dozen points, each of which is worth money.

Ask directly: how many private company sales did your team complete last year, and in what size range.

Financial due diligence, on your own side

The counter-intuitive one, and the highest return on spend available to a seller.

A vendor quality of earnings exercise costs a fraction of the deal value and buys three things that cannot be bought later: time to fix what it finds, documentary evidence of your own adjustments assembled without deadline pressure, and the ability to set the starting point in the diligence negotiation rather than respond to someone else’s.

It is also the only way a seller discovers the problems while there is still more than one bidder.

Tax

Before the process. Not during it.

The structuring decisions that matter (share versus asset sale, the shareholding position, non-trading assets inside the company, the treatment of deferred consideration, personal residence and timing) are mostly tested over a period preceding the disposal. Advice taken once a buyer is engaged can only describe the consequences of a position already fixed.

This is the single most common expensive omission in founder sales, and it costs more than any negotiating point in the agreement.

The others, as needed

Pensions, where there is a defined benefit scheme: a scheme in deficit is a liability that can shape the whole transaction.

Commercial or market diligence, usually buyer-side, occasionally worth commissioning as a vendor exercise where the growth case is the valuation case.

A fairness opinion, where directors have duties to shareholders who are not party to the negotiation: in a management buyout, a sale with minorities, or a transaction with a related party. It is a governance document, not a valuation service, and it exists to evidence that the board took advice.

Insurance broking, where warranty insurance is being used, running in parallel with the disclosure exercise rather than after it.

What fees do to behaviour

Worth thinking about explicitly, because the structure changes the incentive.

  • A high retainer with a low success fee pays the adviser whether or not the deal completes, and reduces the marginal reward for pushing the last pound.
  • A flat percentage of consideration aligns the adviser with completing rather than with maximising: the difference between £19m and £20m is a small fraction of their fee and a large fraction of your proceeds.
  • A ratchet above a threshold addresses that, and is the structure most worth negotiating for.
  • Fees on deferred consideration should be payable when the money is, not at completion. A seller paying a success fee at closing on an earn-out that never pays out is funding someone else’s optimism.
  • Legal fees are hourly in most of the market. Agree an estimate against a defined scope, and agree what happens when the scope changes, because it will.

The combination that works

For a profitable mid-market business going to market: a corporate finance adviser running the process, specialist transaction counsel, a vendor financial diligence exercise, and a tax position settled a year earlier. Everything else is situational.

A seller with that team is negotiating with support. A seller with a long-standing accountant and a general commercial solicitor is negotiating with a buyer who has all four.