Skip to content
← Resources / Articles
Deal process4 min read

Who actually has to say yes: how a €25bn bank deal died on its own share register

Monte dei Paschi's offer for Banco BPM was not blocked by a regulator or a rival. It was voted down by Monte dei Paschi's own shareholders, while the target's largest shareholder refused to sell. Both failures are available to a company worth a thousandth as much.

All M&A Research

Deal structure and process

Updated
A Nordic city seen across open water on a clear day.
A Nordic city seen across open water on a clear day.

Key takeaways

  • Monte dei Paschi needed a two-thirds majority of its own shareholders to issue the stock for its offer. It did not get close: reporting puts the vote at 91% against.
  • Separately, Crédit Agricole (holder of about 29.3% of the target, Banco BPM) had already said it would not tender its shares, calling the offer not attractive enough.
  • Neither obstacle was a regulator, a rival bid or a financing problem. Both were shareholders exercising rights they already had.
  • Before you agree anything, write down every person whose signature or vote the deal actually needs. On a private company that list is usually longer than the board thinks.

In August 2026 Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena confirmed two share-based offers: one for Banco BPM and one for Banca Generali, together worth a reported €34bn. On 29 October its own shareholders were asked to approve the share issue needed to pay for them. According to Reuters’ reporting of the meeting, 91% of the votes cast were against. The offers were declared lapsed the following day.

M&A News now carries the Banco BPM transaction with the status Terminated. No competition authority rejected it. No higher bid beat it. The chief executive had announced it, the board had backed it, and it still did not happen, because the people who owned the acquirer declined to fund it.

What makes this instructive is that the deal faced two independent obstacles, and either one alone would have been enough.

On the buy side, the acquirer needed its own shareholders. Paying in stock means issuing stock, and issuing stock needs a shareholder vote: in this case, on the reporting, a two-thirds majority. Ahead of the meeting, Francesco Gaetano Caltagirone’s holding company FGC, with a reported 10.26% of Monte dei Paschi, had said it would vote against. Delfin and Edizione were reported to favour a rival approach for Monte dei Paschi itself. Between them those holders accounted for close to a third of the share capital, which, against a two-thirds threshold, is arithmetic rather than argument.

On the sell side, the target’s largest shareholder would not sell. Crédit Agricole held about 29.3% of Banco BPM. Its chief executive said publicly that it would not tender those shares into the offer, describing the proposal as not attractive enough. An exchange offer that the largest holder of the target has pre-announced it will refuse is not really an offer for the company; it is an offer for whatever is left.

A deal does not need everyone to say yes. It needs a specific list of people to say yes, and most of the work is finding out who is on the list before you need them.

The private-company version of the same thing

It is tempting to file this under “banks” and move on. The structure of the problem is completely general, and in a small company it is usually less visible, because nobody publishes a notice of meeting.

Ask, before you agree terms, who actually has to consent:

  • Shareholders below board level. A founder who left with 12%, a family trust, an early investor, former employees holding options. Depending on the articles and the shareholders’ agreement, a sale may need a special resolution, or a specified majority, or the consent of a particular class.
  • Anyone with a veto in the shareholders’ agreement. Minority protections frequently include consent rights over a sale, a change of control, or the issue of new shares. These are easy to forget because they are rarely exercised: until they are.
  • Drag-along and tag-along rights. Whether you can compel the rest of the register to follow, and on what threshold, determines whether a holdout is an inconvenience or a blockage.
  • Lenders, landlords and major customers. Change-of-control clauses sit in facility agreements, leases and commercial contracts. A clause that lets a key customer terminate on a change of control hands that customer a say in your sale.
  • The buyer’s own approvals. Mirror the question. If your buyer is funded or owned by someone else, find out what they need and when they get it. A buyer whose investment committee has not yet approved is not a buyer.

Why this is cheaper to find out early

A consent you discover during exclusivity is a problem you solve under time pressure, in public view of the buyer, and usually by paying for it. The holder of a veto who learns of it mid-process is in the strongest negotiating position they will ever occupy.

The same logic that applies to separating a carve-out applies here: the work is cheapest before anyone is watching. A current cap table, a read of the articles and the shareholders’ agreement, and a list of change-of-control clauses in the top twenty contracts cost very little when there is no deal on the table.

A note on the wider situation

The Italian banking sector has been through an unusual amount of this over the past two years, and the position is still moving: at the time of writing, approaches involving Monte dei Paschi, Banco BPM and Crédit Agricole’s Italian operations were all reported as live or evolving. The figures and events above are drawn from contemporaneous news reporting rather than from completion filings, and are described as such deliberately. What is settled is the narrow fact this piece is about: the offer was put to the acquirer’s shareholders, the shareholders said no, and the offer lapsed.

Sources

Figures and events in this piece come from news reporting of a live situation, not from transaction filings. They are attributed accordingly.

  • Reuters, reporting of the Monte dei Paschi shareholder meeting of 29 October 2026: rejection of the proposed exchange offer for Banco BPM, with 91% of votes against.
  • Bloomberg reporting, 9 October 2026. The two offers confirmed in August 2026 (Banco BPM at a reported €25.3bn and Banca Generali at €8.7bn, together around €34bn), the two-thirds approval threshold, FGC’s reported 10.26% holding and its opposition, the positions of Delfin and Edizione, and Crédit Agricole’s 29.3% stake in Banco BPM and its refusal to tender.
  • Deal value and status as tracked by M&A News, which lists the transaction as Terminated.