Skip to content
← Resources / Articles
Deal process3 min read

The second buyer is your entire negotiating strategy

Every technique a seller can deploy works by sustaining the possibility that someone else will buy the business. Without that, there is no negotiation: only a conversation about how much to concede.

All M&A Research

Deal structure and process

Updated
An office lobby with a reception desk and a bank of lifts beyond.
An office lobby with a reception desk and a bank of lifts beyond.

Key takeaways

  • Competitive tension is the only real source of leverage in a sale. Preparation, timetables and well-run diligence all work by preserving it, not by substituting for it.
  • Reaching both strategic and financial buyers matters because they price differently: a sponsor solves backwards from a required return, a trade buyer can pay for synergies.
  • A bilateral negotiation is not a process. The price will reflect that, and no amount of negotiating skill recovers the difference.
  • Keep a credible underbidder for as long as the exclusivity agreement permits. The option does not have to be exercised to be worth something.

There is a question worth asking about any piece of advice on selling a company: what does this actually do? Run most of it through that test and the answer is the same. It sustains the possibility that somebody else will buy the business.

That is the mechanism. Not persuasion, not relationship, not the quality of the information memorandum. A buyer improves its offer when it believes the alternative is losing the asset, and stops improving it when it believes otherwise.

Everything else is instrumental to that.

Why the two buyer types are not interchangeable

A process that reaches only one kind of buyer has a ceiling, and the ceiling is set by how that kind of buyer prices.

A financial buyer solves backwards. An LBO model starts with a required return and the debt available and produces the maximum price. That number moves with credit conditions rather than with your trading. If margins widen between your first meeting and exclusivity, the number falls, and nothing about your business has changed.

A trade buyer can pay for synergies. Cost it can remove, revenue it can add, a capability it would otherwise have to build. None of that is available to a sponsor, which is why strategic buyers frequently outbid private equity for the same asset, and why their offers are also harder to predict, because the synergy case is specific to each one.

A serial acquirer buys for permanence. Usually disciplined on price, frequently the most certain to complete.

Running a process that reaches all three is not about collecting offers. It is about ensuring the highest bidder is bidding against someone with a genuinely different valuation method.

What tension is worth, concretely

The things a seller most wants are the things that get conceded under competition and refused without it:

  • A tighter list of conditions
  • A shorter exclusivity period
  • A smaller escrow, released in tranches
  • A warranty cap that is actually a cap
  • An accounting policies schedule drafted in your favour
  • A seat at the table when the adjustment is calculated

None of these cost a buyer anything in headline price, which is exactly why they are available when a buyer is competing and unavailable when it is not. A seller who secures all six has materially improved their outcome without the price moving at all.

This is the argument for settling the mechanics before granting exclusivity rather than after. It is not a legal point. It is the observation that the same requests get different answers depending on who else is in the room.

The underbidder you keep warm

The most under-used asset in a sale process is the party that came second.

Within whatever the exclusivity agreement permits, and it will usually prohibit soliciting, not merely existing, keeping a credible second party informed and interested costs almost nothing and changes the dynamic entirely. A buyer that suspects the process can be restarted behaves differently from one that knows it cannot.

The corollary matters too: tell the underbidders late. A seller who writes to the losing parties the day exclusivity is signed has destroyed their own option for no benefit.

When a bilateral deal is the right answer

This is not an argument that every sale needs a broad auction. There are good reasons to deal with one party:

  • Confidentiality matters more than price. A disclosure to competitors would do real damage.
  • The buyer has a specific, articulable reason to pay more than anyone else.
  • Speed matters more than price, for reasons of health, partnership or circumstance.
  • The relationship is the point, as in a sale to management.

All of those are legitimate. The thing to be clear-eyed about is that each of them is a decision to accept a lower price in exchange for something else. Made deliberately, that is a trade. Made by default, because running a process felt like too much work, it is simply money left behind.

The uncomfortable conclusion

Most of what determines the outcome of a sale is settled before the negotiation starts: whether there is competition, and whether the seller preserved it. The negotiation itself is where that structure gets expressed, not where it gets created.

Which means the skill that matters most is not negotiating. It is process design, and it happens months before anyone makes an offer.