Deal terms
Warranty insurance quietly changed what a seller should accept
The median escrow on an uninsured deal is 11.1% of the price. On an insured one it is 2.8%. Most sellers still negotiate the hol…
9 November 2026 · 3 min
A seller can spend six weeks arguing a warranty schedule down and then hand over a disclosure letter that gives most of it back, or a thin one that leaves the claim open. Nobody reads it until it matters.
All M&A Research
Deal structure and process
Updated
Key takeaways
In the final fortnight of a transaction, two documents are being finished at once. The purchase agreement, which everyone is watching, and the disclosure letter, which the principals usually see for the first time three days before signing.
The second one determines what the first one is worth.
A warranty is a statement of fact. If it is untrue the buyer has a claim, subject to the caps, thresholds and time limits negotiated in the agreement.
Disclosure is the exception machine. Anything properly disclosed against a warranty is carved out of it: the buyer cannot claim for something it was told about before signing. The letter is the list of those exceptions, warranty by warranty, with supporting documents attached or referenced.
So the negotiation that happens in the agreement, the cap, the de minimis, the survival periods, the knowledge qualifiers, sets the frame. The letter decides what is inside it.
The seller’s instinct is to say as little as possible, on the view that disclosure looks like admission. It is exactly backwards.
Every unqualified warranty is a promise. A seller who knows about an employment grievance, a contract in dispute, a historic VAT treatment that might not hold, or a product complaint, and does not disclose it, has warranted that it does not exist. If the buyer later discovers it, that is a breach, and the first £500,000 of a warranty claim is a great deal more painful than the two paragraphs of disclosure that would have prevented it.
The escrow exists precisely to fund that outcome. Disclosure is how a seller keeps the escrow and gets it released.
The opposite failure is a letter that arrives late and surprises the buyer. A material matter appearing for the first time in a draft disclosure letter, five days before signing, triggers the reaction a seller least wants: new diligence, a specific indemnity, a larger retention, or a conversation about price.
The fix is not to disclose less. It is to disclose earlier, inside the diligence process, where it is one item among many rather than a revelation at the end. A matter raised in week two is a diligence finding. The same matter raised in week nine is a problem.
The practical rule: nothing should appear in the disclosure letter that the buyer is seeing for the first time. The letter records what was disclosed. It is not the occasion of the disclosure.
Markets differ, and this is the single biggest variable in how much work the letter has to do.
General disclosure treats everything in the data room as disclosed against all warranties. Where a buyer accepts it, the seller’s specific disclosure burden falls sharply, though the better practice is still to disclose specifically against the warranties that matter, because a buyer can later argue that burying a document in a folder of four thousand files was not fair disclosure.
Specific disclosure only requires each exception to be identified against the warranty it qualifies, with enough detail for the buyer to understand it. That is a substantial drafting exercise and it is where the final weeks of a deal disappear.
Which applies is negotiated in the agreement, usually in a sentence that looks procedural. It is not. It is worth more than several of the clauses being argued over at the same time.
This one catches sellers who have done everything else right.
Warranty and indemnity insurance covers unknown matters. Anything disclosed is a known matter, and known matters are excluded from the policy. So the better the disclosure, the narrower the cover. This is not a quirk of one insurer: the use of insurance in place of a large escrow is now a standard feature of private deal terms, which is precisely why the disclosure exercise has become the thing that decides how much cover a buyer actually has.1
That is not an argument for disclosing less. An undisclosed known matter is both a warranty breach and, potentially, a basis for the insurer to decline. It is an argument for sequencing. The underwriting process and the disclosure exercise have to run together, with the broker seeing the draft letter early enough to say which exclusions will follow and whether anything can be insured specifically.
A seller who places the policy first and writes the letter afterwards has bought cover for a set of risks that the letter is about to remove.
The warranty schedule is negotiated in meetings everyone attends. The letter is assembled in the background by people who were not at them. That is why it decides the outcome.
SRS Acquiom’s 2026 private-target M&A deal terms study, covering more than 2,300 transactions closed between 2020 and 2025, as summarised in Fasken, “Private M&A Deal Trends to Watch: Key Takeaways from SRS Acquiom’s 2026 Study” (7 May 2026). The sample is predominantly US buyers, so treat the levels as a reference point rather than a UK market rate. ↩
Related
Deal terms
The median escrow on an uninsured deal is 11.1% of the price. On an insured one it is 2.8%. Most sellers still negotiate the hol…
9 November 2026 · 3 min
Deal terms
In twenty-five years only one buyer has walked away on a material adverse change and had a court agree. Sellers should still rea…
9 November 2026 · 4 min
Deal structure
Buyers want assets and sellers want shares, for the same reason: one of them leaves the history behind. Where that argument land…
9 November 2026 · 4 min