Skip to content

Glossary · Deal terms

Specific indemnity

A pound-for-pound promise to cover a particular identified risk. Unlike a warranty it does not require a breach, is usually outside the general cap, and is how diligence findings end up on the seller's account.

Deal terms
Category
16 November 2026
Updated

In one sentence

A pound-for-pound promise to cover a particular identified risk. Unlike a warranty it does not require a breach, is usually outside the general cap, and is how diligence findings end up on the seller's account.

What it is

Diligence finds something specific. A historic VAT treatment that may not hold. Contractors who look like employees. A live customer dispute. Contaminated land.

Neither side can size it reliably, so it is not priced. Instead the seller agrees to cover it if it crystallises.

That last row is the one sellers find counter-intuitive. Disclosing a problem protects you from a warranty claim about it. It also identifies it as exactly the thing the buyer will want an indemnity for.

How findings become indemnities

The sequence is predictable:

  1. Diligence identifies a specific exposure.
  2. Neither side can quantify it with confidence.
  3. The buyer will not take the risk at the agreed price.
  4. The seller will not accept a price reduction for something that may never happen.
  5. An indemnity bridges the gap, usually with part of the escrow earmarked against it.

Framed that way it is a reasonable instrument: it transfers a risk nobody can price, rather than guessing at a number. The difficulty is that it arrives during exclusivity, and the seller is negotiating alone.

What to negotiate

  • A cap, even if separate from the general warranty cap. An uncapped indemnity on a tax matter is an open-ended liability.
  • A time limit matched to the actual risk: the statutory assessment window for a tax exposure, not indefinite. For income tax that is four years, six where the loss was careless and twenty where it was deliberate.1
  • Conduct of claims. Who runs the defence if a third party sues or a tax authority enquires. A seller paying for the outcome should have a say in how it is handled, and at minimum a right to be consulted and to approve any settlement.
  • A de minimis, so trivial amounts are not administered.
  • Mitigation and recovery. The buyer should credit insurance proceeds, third-party recoveries and any tax relief obtained.
  • No double recovery with the warranties or the price adjustment.
  • An escrow earmarked against it, released when the risk expires, which turns an open liability into a defined, time-limited one.

Common mistakes

  1. Treating it as a drafting detail. It is a separate liability regime, frequently outside the cap and running longer than the warranties.
  2. Conceding conduct of claims. The seller pays for the outcome while the buyer runs the negotiation. Notice, consultation and approval of any settlement are the minimum.
  3. Accepting it uncapped. Even a cap well above the likely exposure converts an open liability into a bounded one.
  4. Not excluding double recovery. The same matter should not be recoverable under the indemnity, the warranties and the price adjustment.
  5. Not earmarking escrow against it. An indemnity backed by a defined, time-limited retention is a different proposition from an open promise.
  6. Disclosing a problem without fixing it first. Disclosure defeats a warranty claim and simultaneously identifies the thing the buyer will want indemnified.

See the twelve findings that most often produce one in twelve diligence findings that change the price.

Sources

  1. Taxes Management Act 1970, “Section 34: Ordinary time limit of 4 years” and “Section 36: Loss of tax brought about carelessly or deliberately etc”. ↩

Frequently asked questions

What is a specific indemnity in a share purchase agreement?

An undertaking by the seller to reimburse the buyer for loss arising from a named, identified matter. A tax exposure, a live dispute, an environmental issue, a contractor's employment status. The buyer does not have to prove a breach of warranty or quantify loss in the same way; it simply recovers what it has paid out.

How is an indemnity different from a warranty?

A warranty is a statement of fact; the buyer must show it was untrue and prove loss measured by the reduction in value of the company. An indemnity is a promise to pay on the happening of a defined event, usually pound for pound, and often without the de minimis, basket, cap or time limits that apply to warranties.

Can a specific indemnity be insured?

Sometimes. Warranty and indemnity insurance excludes known matters by default, but insurers will occasionally write specific cover for an identified issue, a contingent tax risk, for example, as a separate policy or an affirmative cover extension, at a price reflecting the known exposure.